IEEE 802.16 Recirculation Ballot #4a: Voting Report

Final results (finalized 2002-03-15), updated to include changes through comment resolution of Session #18.

Motion: To forward IEEE P802.16a/D2-2002 for IEEE Sponsor Ballot.

Dates: 8-25 February 2002

See also:

Summary

Approve Dis Votes Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>=75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Motion
Approved
91 15 106 85.8% Yes 15 121 178 68.0% Yes 0 Yes

Ballot Details (Modified following comment resolution.)

[Note: "Decline" means "did not return a ballot".]

Name\Family Name\Given Vote in Ballot #4 Vote in Recirc #4a (default is LB#4 vote)
Agrawal Aditya Approve, No Comments  
An Song Approve, No Comments  
Antonello Gordon Disapprove Approve, Comments
Arefi Reza Approve, No Comments  
Ariyavisitakul S. Lek Approve, No Comments  
Arrakoski Jori Disapprove Disapprove
Arunachalam Arun Decline  
Audeh Malik Approve, Comments Approve, Comments
Avera Drayt Decline  
Avivi Eli Approve, No Comments  
Baragar Ian Approve, No Comments  
Baugh C.R. (Rick) Decline  
Belfiore Carlos Decline  
Benyamin-Seeyar Anader Approve, Comments Approve, Comments
Brennan James Abstain for Lack of Time  
Bushue Carl Approve, No Comments**  
Buskila Baruch Approve, No Comments  
Caso Gregory Decline  
Chang Yuankai Approve, No Comments  
Chang Dean Approve, No Comments  
Chauncey David Approve, No Comments  
Chayat Naftali Approve, No Comments Disapprove
Chayer Rémi Approve, No Comments Approve, Comments
Coles Ronald Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise  
Condie Mary Decline  
Cornelius James Abstain for Lack of Time  
Costa José Approve, Comments  
Donahue Michael Approve, No Comments  
Dotan Amos Approve, No Comments  
Durand Roger Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise  
Edmonston Brian Approve, No Comments  
Eidson Brian Disapprove Approve, Comments*
Eilts Henry Approve, No Comments  
Eklund Carl Disapprove Approve, Comments
El-Damhougy Hesham Decline  
Erceg Vinko Decline  
Fishel George Decline  
Florea Adrian Decline  
Foster Robert Decline  
Freedman Avraham Approve, Comments Approve, Comments
Garrett Andrew Approve, No Comments  
Garrison G. Jack Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise  
Gieschen Brian Disapprove Disapprove
Goldhammer Marianna Approve, No Comments Disapprove
Guillemette Phil Decline  
Hadad Zion Approve, No Comments  
Hakim Joseph Approve, Comments  
Halachmi Baruch Decline  
Hamilton Michael Abstain for Lack of Time  
Harteneck Moritz Approve, Comments  
Hatim Baya Approve, No Comments  
Hebron Yoav Approve, No Comments  
Heise Bob Decline  
Hosur Srinath Approve, No Comments  
Hum Coleman Approve, No Comments  
Hunter Wayne Decline  
Husson David Approve, Comments  
Jackson Du Wayne Approve, Comments  
Jacobsen Eric Disapprove Disapprove
Jamali Hamadi Approve, No Comments  
Joo Panyuh Decline Disapprove
Jorgensen Jacob Approve, No Comments  
Kaitz Tal Disapprove Approve, Comments*
Kang Inchul Abstain for Lack of Time  
Kasslin Mika Disapprove Approve, Comments*
Kelly Phil Approve, No Comments  
Kelman Ofer Approve, No Comments  
Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments  
Kim John Decline  
Kitroser Itzik Approve, Comments Approve, Comments
Klein Allan Decline  
Klein Jay Approve, No Comments  
Kolze Thomas Disapprove  
Kostas Demosthenes Decline  
Krinock Jerome Disapprove Approve, Comments*
Krishnamoorthy Rajeev Decline  
Kwak Byung-Jae Decline  
Labs Jonathan Approve, No Comments Approve, Comments
Langley John Approve, No Comments Approve, Comments
Lee Chin-Chen Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise  
Leiba Yigal Approve, Comments* Approve, Comments
Leng Minfei Decline  
Levinson Moshe Approve, No Comments  
Lewis Barry Decline  
Licardie Sergio Decline  
Liebetreu John Approve, No Comments  
Lindh Lars Disapprove Disapprove
Lo Titus Decline  
Lou Hui-Ling Approve, Comments  
Lu Willie Decline  
Lycklama Heinz Disapprove  
Malkemes Robert Decline  
Marin J. Scott Disapprove Approve, No Comments
Markarian Garik Approve, No Comments  
Marks Roger Disapprove Approve, Comments
McCallister Ronald Abstain for Lack of Time  
McGregor Andy Decline  
McKown Russell Approve, No Comments  
Mehta Sushil Decline  
Meyer Ronald Approve, No Comments  
Middleton Andrew Approve, No Comments  
Mitlin Vlad Decline  
Mody Apurva Approve, Comments Disapprove
Moghe Sanjay Decline  
Mollenauer James Decline  
Monk Anton Decline  
Murias Ronald Disapprove Approve, No Comments
Music Wayne Decline  
Myers William Decline  
Nadeau Jim Decline  
Nelson Bob Disapprove Approve, Comments
Olszewski Kim Approve, No Comments  
Padan Uzi Approve, No Comments  
Paff Mike Disapprove Approve, No Comments
Patel Manish Decline  
Peirce Kenneth Approve, Comments  
Ponnuswamy Subbu Disapprove Approve, Comments*
Quilez Vicente Decline  
Rafie Manouchehr Decline  
Ran Moshe Approve, Comments  
Regev Einan Decline  
Reible Stanley Approve, No Comments  
Resheff Guy Decline  
Rhodes Valentine Decline  
Robinson Gene Approve, No Comments  
Roehr Walt Approve, Comments  
Sarajedini Amir Approve, Comments  
Sarca Octavian Decline  
Sari Hikmet Approve, Comments  
Satapathy Durga Approve, No Comments  
Sater Glen Decline  
Scaringi Vito Decline  
Scarpa Carl Approve, No Comments  
Schwartz Randall Approve, No Comments  
Segal Yossi Approve, Comments  
Selea Radu Decline  
Seller Olivier Approve, No Comments  
Shahar Menashe Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise  
Shan Tie-Jun Decline  
Shani David Decline  
Shenhav Chaim Approve, No Comments  
Shirali Chet Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise  
Simkins James Approve, No Comments  
Singh Manoneet Disapprove Approve, No Comments
Singleton Ken Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise  
Smith Steven Decline  
Son Jung Je Decline Approve, No Comments
Sonander Sean Approve, No Comments  
Stamatelos George Decline  
Stambaugh Karl Abstain for Lack of Time  
Stanwood Kenneth Approve, Comments  
Stewart Michael Approve, Comments*  
Struhsaker Paul Disapprove Approve, Comments
Sydor John Approve, No Comments  
Taylor Shawn Disapprove Disapprove
Tellado Jose Decline  
Thompson Paul Decline  
Tiram-Regev Ayelet Approve, No Comments  
Trinkwon David Disapprove  
van Waes Nico Disapprove Disapprove
Varma Subir Disapprove Approve, No Comments
Wachira Muya Decline  
Wang Arthur Abstain for Lack of Time  
Wang Lei Disapprove Disapprove
Wang Chao-Chun Decline  
Wang Stanley Approve, No Comments  
Ward Robert Decline Abstain for Lack of Time
Watkins Larry Approve, No Comments**  
Whitehead Philip Approve, No Comments  
Whiting Robert Approve, No Comments  
Williams David Decline  
Wise Curt Decline  
Yanover Vladimir Approve, Comments Disapprove
Ye Huanchun Approve, No Comments  
Zeng Chaoming Decline  
Zhang Wenhan Approve, No Comments  
Zuniga Juan Carlos Approve, No Comments  
Zyskowski Paul Decline  
*Changed from "Disapprove"
**Changed from "Decline"

Nonmember comments

Name\Family Name\Given Ballot #4 Recirc #4a
Cao Fengming - X
Wang Jiacheng - X
Wang Hai - X