IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #18: Ballot Report

Letter Ballot #18 progress, in inverse chronological order:

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #18: Announcement {CLOSED}
Please see also comments regarding Reference [4].

Summary Results

Report Date Approve Dis Sum Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Approval
2005/05/25 131 40 171 .77 Yes 17 188 287 .66 Yes 0 Yes*

*Pending comments resolution and recirculation.

Ballot Details

[ Updated 2005-05-03 ]
Note: This report is infrequently updated while the ballot is open. However, you may check a real-time report of ballot submittals.

Name\Family Name\Given Letter Ballot #18
Abrishami Ray Approve, No Comments
Agis Edward Disapprove
Agrawal Aditya Disapprove
Al-Dabagh Baraa Disapprove
Alamouti Siavash -
Aliotta Mario Approve, No Comments
Amitabha Ghosh -
Andelman Dov Disapprove
Antonello Gordon Approve, No Comments
Athalye Sanjeev Approve, No Comments
Avivi Eli Approve, No Comments
Ayyr Ravi -
Baek Sung Kwan Approve, No Comments
Banerjea Raja -
Barber Phillip Approve, No Comments
Baum Kevin Approve, No Comments
Bentov Izhar -
Bhalla Rajesh Approve, No Comments
Blankenship Yufei -
Bogenfeld Eckard Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Brooks Terri Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Brown Thomas -
Cai Sean Approve, No Comments
Carlo Jim -
Castelow David Approve, No Comments
Cavalli Giulio Approve, No Comments
Cha Jaesun Approve, No Comments
Chae Chan-Byoung Approve, No Comments
Chan John Approve, No Comments
Chang Dean Approve, No Comments
Chang Jae Hwan Disapprove
Chang Sungcheol Approve, No Comments
Chang Yong Disapprove
Chao Jim Approve, No Comments
Chauvin Todd -
Chayat Naftali -
Chayer RÈmi Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Chen Jennifer Approve, No Comments
Chen Tao -
Chen Yuehua (Lucy) Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Chindapol Aik Approve, No Comments
Chion Hua (Mary) Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Cho Jaehee Approve, No Comments
Cho Jaeweon Approve, No Comments
Cho Kihyoung Approve, No Comments
Cho Seokheon Approve, No Comments
Choi Hyoung-Jin -
Chou Joey -
Chun Jin Young Approve, No Comments
Chung Jin Yong Approve, No Comments
Chung Kyuhyuk Approve, No Comments
Costa JosÈ Approve, No Comments
Cote Guy Approve, No Comments
Cudak Mark Disapprove
Dang Meimei -
Dang Shujun Approve, No Comments
Demarty JoÎl Disapprove
Dennett Steve -
Diaine Pascale -
Dondeti Lakshminath -
Dong Xiaolu -
Draper Frank Approve, No Comments
Eastwood Lester Approve, No Comments
Eklund Carl -
Eliaspur Yigal Disapprove
Eline Roger -
Elkayam Oren Approve, No Comments
Etemad Kamran -
Exeler Frank Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Fahldieck Torsten Approve, No Comments
Fan Shijun (James) -
Fang Yonggang Approve, No Comments
Feder Peretz -
Feng Dazi -
Fong Mo-Han Approve, No Comments
Franovici Bogdan Approve, No Comments
Freedman Avraham Approve, Comments
Geipel Mike -
Giesberts Pieter-Paul Approve, No Comments
Goel Nikhil Approve, No Comments
Goldhamer Mariana Disapprove
Golshan Reza -
Guo Jin Approve, No Comments
Guo Qiang Approve, No Comments
Hadad Zion -
Hahn Yung -
Han Jun Approve, No Comments
Hansen Chris Disapprove
Harrang Jeff -
Haskin John -
He Haixiang Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
He Peng -
Hsiao Chang-Lung Approve, No Comments
Huang Haiming Approve, No Comments
Huang Peter -
Huang Zhaoyun (Laura) -
Hui Benjamin -
Humbert John -
Hur Yerang Approve, No Comments
Hwang Ho-Tark -
Hwang InSeok Approve, No Comments
Hwang Seung Ku -
Ibbetson Luke -
Ihm Bin-Chul Approve, No Comments
Iyer Prakash Disapprove
Jain Avinash Approve, No Comments
Jang Jiho Approve, No Comments
Jeon Jaeho Disapprove
Jeong Moo Ryong Approve, No Comments
Jin Yong Seok Approve, No Comments
Johnson Brian Approve, No Comments
Johnston David Approve, No Comments
Joo Panyuh Disapprove
Kaitz Tal Disapprove
Kalavakunta Ravi Approve, No Comments
Kang Hyunjeong Disapprove
Kang Samuel Disapprove
Kelly Ivy Approve, No Comments
Kelman Ofer Approve, No Comments
Kerr Adam Approve, No Comments
Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments
Kim Beomjoon Approve, No Comments
Kim Bong Ho Approve, No Comments
Kim Byoung-Jo Approve, No Comments
Kim Chong-kwon -
Kim Dae-Joong Approve, No Comments
Kim Jaehyeong Approve, No Comments
Kim Jaeyoel Approve, No Comments
Kim JaeYoung Disapprove
Kim Jeong-Heon Disapprove
Kim Jeonghwi Approve, No Comments
Kim Min Sung Approve, No Comments
Kim Ronny (Yong-Ho) Approve, No Comments
Kim Yong Bum Approve, No Comments
Kim Youngho Approve, No Comments
Kim YoungKyun Disapprove
Kitroser Itzik -
Knudsen Chris -
Koh Kang Il -
Koo Changhoi Disapprove
Koorapaty Havish -
Kotecha Lalit Approve, No Comments
Krishnasamy Denesh Approve, No Comments
Kurosawa Yoko -
Kuze Toshiyuki Approve, No Comments
Kwon Dongseung Approve, No Comments
LaBrecque Margaret Disapprove
Labs Jonathan Approve, No Comments
Lai Ming-Yee -
Lamoureux Jules Pierre Approve, No Comments
Lee Chang-jae -
Lee Chi-Chen Approve, No Comments
Lee Jae Hak Approve, No Comments
Lee Seong Choon Approve, No Comments
Lee Sungjin Disapprove
Leiba Yigal Approve, No Comments
Lewis Barry Approve, No Comments
Li Dina Approve, No Comments
Li Jia-Ru Approve, No Comments
Li Jiang Approve, No Comments
Li Jun Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Li Kemin Approve, No Comments
Li Wei -
Li Xiaodong -
Li Yongmao Approve, No Comments
Lim Geunhwi Approve, No Comments
Lim Hyoung Kyu -
Lim Hyoungsoo Approve, No Comments
Lim Sun Ju -
Lindskog Erik -
Lo Titus Approve, No Comments
Lou Hui-Ling Approve, No Comments
Lycklama Heinz Approve, No Comments
Lynch Michael Approve, No Comments
Lyon Daniel Approve, No Comments
Lysejko Martin -
Ma Steve Approve, No Comments
Maeng Seung Joo Disapprove
Maez David Approve, No Comments
Mandin Jeffrey -
Mankin Kevin Approve, No Comments
Marks Roger Disapprove
McGinniss David -
Migaldi Scott Approve, No Comments
Mo Xiu -
Mollenauer James Approve, No Comments
Mont-Reynaud Ollivier Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Moon Dong-Il (Stephan) -
Muenzner Roland Approve, No Comments
Murakami Fumio -
Murias Ronald Approve, Comments
Nakamura Kenichi Approve, No Comments
Nam Seung Hoon Approve, No Comments
Natarajan K.S. -
Nguyen Nha -
Nitsche Gunnar Disapprove
Odlyzko Paul Approve, No Comments
Oh Min Seok Approve, No Comments
Olfat Masoud Approve, No Comments
Or Alan -
Ovadia Shlomo Disapprove
Park Joonho -
Park Pyung-Su -
Park Young Man -
Park Youngsoo Approve, No Comments
Patel Vijay Approve, No Comments
Pearman Trevor -
Pechner Dave -
Petti Bonnie Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Phillips Greg Approve, No Comments
Piggin Paul Disapprove
Poisson Sebastien Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Popper Ambroise Approve, No Comments
Priebe Russell -
Puthenkulam Jose Disapprove
Rath Kamlesh Approve, No Comments
Reid Anthony -
Reifsnider Eric Approve, No Comments
Retnasothie Francis -
Reudink Douglas -
Reynolds Russ -
Riegel Maximilian Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Rogers Chris -
Rogers Shane Approve, No Comments
Roh Wonil Disapprove
Ruck Herbert -
Rush Charles Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ryu Byung-Han -
Ryu Kiseon Approve, No Comments
Sago Andrew -
Salvekar Atul Disapprove
Sanderson Michael -
Schumacher Gregory -
Schwartz Randall -
Seagren Christian -
Segal Yossi Approve, No Comments
Selea Radu -
Shakouri Mohammad -
Shankaranarayanan N.K. Approve, No Comments
Shasha Eli Approve, No Comments
Simkins James Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Solomon David -
Son Jung Je Approve, No Comments
Son Yeong Moon Disapprove
Stanwood Kenneth Disapprove
Stewart Kenneth -
Tang Chunhui Approve, No Comments
Tani Kazuki -
Taylor Shawn -
Tcha Yongjoo Approve, No Comments
Tong Wen Approve, No Comments
Ullmann Rainer Disapprove
Vafai Mano Approve, No Comments
Vasudevan Subramanian -
Verbin Eyal Approve, No Comments
Vook Frederick Approve, No Comments
Walma Mathys Disapprove
Wang Arthur Approve, No Comments
Wang Guo Qiang Approve, No Comments
Wang Irving Approve, No Comments
Wang Jing -
Wang Lei Disapprove
Wang Stanley -
Watanabe Yasuyuki -
Wei Xuefei Approve, No Comments
Wennstrom Mattias Approve, No Comments
Weon Dong-Jun -
Wieczorek Alfred -
Wu Geng Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Wu Jun -
Wunsch Janice -
Yaghoobi Hassan Disapprove
Yang Weidong -
Yaniv Ran Disapprove
Yanover Vladimir Disapprove
Yeh Choong-Il Approve, No Comments
Yeh Sang-Kuk -
Yeo Kunmin -
Yoon Chulsik Approve, No Comments
Yoon Soon Young Disapprove
Yu Chang Wahn -
Yun Jungnam Approve, No Comments
Zhang Jianzhong Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Zhang Wenfeng -
Zhang Wenzhong -
Zhu Keqiang -
Zhu Peiying Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

*Post-deadline.
**Converted from Disapprove after deadline or based on comment resolution.