Re: [RPRWG] Opening of Recirculation Ballot on Draft 2.7 of P802.17
Are there any post meeting comment resolutions available for D2.6?
Best Regards,
Fredrik
---------------------------------------------
Fredrik Davik
Phone: +47 67 82 83 88
Mobile: +47 45 24 91 88
Fax: +47 67 82 82 01
Switchboard: +47 67 82 82 00
mailto:bjornfd@xxxxxxxxx
http://heim.ifi.uio.no/~bjornfd
http://www.simula.no/people_one.php?people_id=22
Simula Research Laboratory
P.O.Box 134, Lysaker
N-1325 Lysaker
Norway
Mike Takefman <tak@xxxxxxxxx> writes:
> Announcement of opening of 802.17 WG Recirculation Ballot and Comment Period
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Dear IEEE 802.17 Working Group Member:
>
> This e-mail is to advise you of the opening of the IEEE 802.17
> Working Group Recirculation Ballot for IEEE P802.17 (Resilient
> Packet Ring), Draft 2.7, otherwise known as:
>
> Information Technology - Telecommunications and information
> exchange between systems - Local & Metropolitan Area Networks -
> Specific requirements - Resilient Packet Ring Access Method and
> Physical Layer Specifications
>
> The comment period opens on Tuesday, 28 October 2003 at 9.00 AM PDT and
> closes on Wednesday, 12 November 2003 at 10:00 AM PDT.
>
> THIS IS AN 802.17 BALLOT. All valid ballots (votes on the document)
> that are submitted along with comments will be counted towards approval
> or disapproval of the draft. A valid ballot is one that is cast by a
> voting member of the 802.17 group that also voted (approve, disapprove
> or abstain) during the D2.3 ballot.
>
> All properly submitted comments will be resolved during the November
> 2003 Plenary meeting in Albuquerque. Note that you are only required to
> submit a ballot if you wish to change your existing vote. If you do not
> submit a ballot, your last recorded vote will be carried forward unchanged.
>
> Further, if you had voted Disapprove on D2.3, D2.4, D2.5 or D2.6
> along with applicable Technically Binding comments, and all of
> these comments have been resolved to your satisfaction, then you
> are requested to submit new Technically Binding comments if you wish
> to maintain your vote as Disapprove. If you wish to change your
> vote from Disapprove to Approve in spite of any outstanding
> Technically Binding comments, please submit a new ballot as well.
>
> A copy of this draft can be found on our password-protected website:
>
> http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/
>
> The draft is posted in Adobe "pdf" document format and can be
> viewed online, or downloaded and printed. You will need a copy of
> Adobe's Acrobat Reader (4.0 or higher) to view or print the draft. This
> software is available for free downloading from Adobe at:
> http://www.adobe.com/prodindex/acrobat/readstep.html.
>
> The draft prints out as 754 paper pages. It is copyrighted by the IEEE
> and is for your review and balloting purposes only. It should not be
> copied or otherwise distributed.
>
> As this is a RECIRCULATION BALLOT, only changed sections of the draft
> (i.e., those with changebars along the left hand side) are now open for
> comments. Please refrain from commenting against draft text that does
> not have a changebar next to it.
>
> The ballot/comment executable with instructions is available at:
>
> http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/P802_17D2_7_CRD_Win.zip
> or
> http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/P802_17D2_7_CRD_Mac.sit
>
> The comment executable is designed for systems capable of running
> Windows or Macintosh based programs. Please read the comment
> instructions carefully.
>
> The set of Technically Binding comments that were rejected at the
> October 2003 Interim meeting is supplied in the file:
> http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/rejectedCommentaryData.USR
>
> You may review the rejected comments by simply double-clicking on the
> above file (after first downloading the ballot/comment executable). You
> may, if you wish, change your vote from Approve to Disapprove, or
> maintain your Disapprove vote, on the basis that one or more of these
> Technically Binding comments should not have been rejected. In this
> case, please submit a new ballot with accompanying Technically Binding
> comments indicating the reason for your Disapprove vote.
>
> Please submit ballots and comments (using the output of your comment
> executable) electronically to Tom Alexander at:
> tom@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
>
> If you should have any questions, problems or comments please contact:
> Mike Takefman
> Chair, IEEE 802.17 Working Group
> Office: 613-254-3399 Fax: 613-254-3778
> tak@xxxxxxxxx
>
> Tom Alexander
> Chief Editor, IEEE 802.17 Working Group
> Cell: 503-803-3534 Fax: 503-632-7621
> tom@xxxxxxxxxxxx
>
>
> NOTE:
>
> According to the RPR Working Group ballot process, official ballots will
> only be accepted from voting members of the 802.17 Working Group. The
> draft is also, however, being circulated to those who have been
> participating in the standardization process but are not members of the
> Working Group, in order to provide a wide review of the document and to
> solicit comments.
>
> You should also be aware that Technical-Binding (TB) comments are not
> required to be tracked amongst non-Working Group members. If a TB is
> entered by a person who is not a Working Group member, and this person
> is not at attendance and readily available at the interim meeting to
> review the Working Group's response, we will not obligate the editors or
> staff of 802.17 to track down the commenter and obtain the sign-off.
>
>
> Best Regards,
>
> Mike Takefman
>
> --
> Michael Takefman tak@xxxxxxxxx
> Distinguished Engineer, Cisco Systems
> Chair IEEE 802.17 Stds WG
> 3000 Innovation Dr, Ottawa, Canada, K2K 3E8
> voice: 613-254-3399 cell:613-220-6991
> Announcement of opening of 802.17 WG Recirculation Ballot and Comment Period
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Dear IEEE 802.17 Working Group Member:
>
> This e-mail is to advise you of the opening of the IEEE 802.17 Working Group
> Recirculation Ballot for IEEE P802.17 (Resilient Packet Ring), Draft 2.7,
> otherwise known as:
>
> Information Technology - Telecommunications and information exchange between
> systems - Local & Metropolitan Area Networks - Specific requirements -
> Resilient Packet Ring Access Method and Physical Layer Specifications
>
> The comment period opens on Tuesday, 28 October 2003 at 9.00 AM PDT and
> closes on Wednesday, 12 November 2003 at 10:00 AM PDT.
>
> THIS IS AN 802.17 BALLOT. All valid ballots (votes on the document) that are
> submitted along with comments will be counted towards approval or disapproval
> of the draft. A valid ballot is one that is cast by a voting member of the
> 802.17 group that also voted (approve, disapprove or abstain) during the
> D2.3 ballot.
>
> All properly submitted comments will be resolved during the November 2003
> Plenary meeting in Albuquerque. Note that you are only required to submit a
> ballot if you wish to change your existing vote. If you do not submit a
> ballot, your last recorded vote will be carried forward unchanged.
>
> Further, if you had voted Disapprove on D2.3, D2.4, D2.5 or D2.6 along with
> applicable Technically Binding comments, and all of these comments have
> been resolved to your satisfaction, then you are requested to submit new
> Technically Binding comments if you wish to maintain your vote as
> Disapprove. If you wish to change your vote from Disapprove to Approve in
> spite of any outstanding Technically Binding comments, please submit a new
> ballot as well.
>
> A copy of this draft can be found on our password-protected website:
>
> http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/
>
> The draft is posted in Adobe "pdf" document format and can be viewed online,
> or downloaded and printed. You will need a copy of Adobe's Acrobat Reader
> (4.0 or higher) to view or print the draft. This software is available for
> free downloading from Adobe at:
> http://www.adobe.com/prodindex/acrobat/readstep.html.
> The draft prints out as 754 paper pages. It is copyrighted by the IEEE and
> is for your review and balloting purposes only. It should not be copied or
> otherwise distributed.
>
> As this is a RECIRCULATION BALLOT, only changed sections of the draft (i.e.,
> those with changebars along the left hand side) are now open for comments.
> Please refrain from commenting against draft text that does not have a
> changebar next to it.
>
> The ballot/comment executable with instructions is available at:
> http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/P802_17D2_7_CRD_Win.zip
> or http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/P802_17D2_7_CRD_Mac.sit
> The comment executable is designed for systems capable of running Windows
> or Macintosh based programs. Please read the comment instructions carefully.
>
> The set of Technically Binding comments that were rejected at the October
> 2003 Interim meeting is supplied in the file:
> http://www.ieee802.org/17/member/draftballots/d2_7/rejectedCommentaryData.USR
>
> You may review the rejected comments by simply double-clicking on the above
> file (after first downloading the ballot/comment executable). You may, if you
> wish, change your vote from Approve to Disapprove, or maintain your Disapprove
> vote, on the basis that one or more of these Technically Binding comments
> should not have been rejected. In this case, please submit a new ballot with
> accompanying Technically Binding comments indicating the reason for your
> Disapprove vote.
>
> Please submit ballots and comments (using the output of your comment
> executable) electronically to Tom Alexander at:
> tom@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
>
> If you should have any questions, problems or comments please contact:
> Mike Takefman
> Chair, IEEE 802.17 Working Group
> Office: 613-254-3399 Fax: 613-254-3333
> tak@xxxxxxxxx
>
> Tom Alexander
> Chief Editor, IEEE 802.17 Working Group
> Cell: 503-803-3534 Fax: 503-632-7621
> tom@xxxxxxxxxxxx
>
>
> NOTE:
>
> According to the RPR Working Group ballot process, official ballots will only
> be accepted from voting members of the 802.17 Working Group. The draft is also,
> however, being circulated to those who have been participating in the
> standardization process but are not members of the Working Group, in order to
> provide a wide review of the document and to solicit comments.
>
> You should also be aware that Technical-Binding (TB) comments are not required
> to be tracked amongst non-Working Group members. If a TB is entered by a person
> who is not a Working Group member, and this person is not at attendance and
> readily available at the interim meeting to review the Working Group's response,
> we will not obligate the editors or staff of 802.17 to track down the commenter
> and obtain the sign-off.
>
> Best Regards,
>
> Mike Takefman
> Chair, IEEE 802.17 Working Group
> Office: 613-254-3399 Fax: 613-254-3333
> tak@xxxxxxxxx