Re: [EFM-Copper] RE: [EFM] (forward) progress in EFM copper

["Behrooz Rezvani" <brezvani@xxxxxxxxxx>]

i am not going to get into nit picking and dissecting of the words here

people can look at proposals and decide for themselves whether the list enjoys a very strong support or not.

that was the message

 

----- Original Message -----

From: Wei, Dong

To: 'Behrooz Rezvani'

Cc: stds-802-3-efm-copper@ieee.org ; stds-802-3-efm@ieee.org

Sent: Tuesday, July 02, 2002 8:00 AM

Subject: RE: [EFM-Copper] RE: [EFM] (forward) progress in EFM copper

Behrooz,

 

You made the following statement in your last e-mail:

 

"The fact is that all the major semiconductor companies and others have supported the long reach proposal by Doug Artman.

 

1)Intel, 2) Ti, 3)ST Micro, 4)ADI, 5)Broadcom, 6)GlobeSpan, .... the list goes on."

 

This is apparently NOT a fact. Many major semiconductor companies (e.g., Lucent, Infineon, AMD, ... the list goes on) are not on the supporter list of Artman's proposal.

 

On the other hand, Intel and GlobeSpan supported the SHDSL baseline proposal as well.

 

Dong