[STDS-802-3-EPOC] ePoll results for: Unofficial IEEE P802.3bn Task Force eStraw Poll #rfspectrum_5
Online straw poll closed at 2013-05-31 18:00:00 for:
Unofficial IEEE P802.3bn Task Force eStraw Poll #rfspectrum_5
Internal Exclusion sub-bands maximum occupied spectrum Question: (formatted for text):
"What is the maximum of precentage of occupied spectrum can be
covered by internal exclusion sub-bands? Where "occupied spectrum"
is the difference between the frequency of the highest modulated
subcarrier and the frequency of the lowest modulated subcarrier, of
the of OFDM channel. (Reference: ad hoc committee minutes: RF
Spectrum_Minutes 5/28/13 )"
----------------------------------------------------
Vote type: Single answer selection per voter.
Summary of votes per answer (percent of total):
0) 20% = 2 (16.7%)
1) 30% = 3 (25.0%)
2) 40% = 1 (8.3%)
3) Other percentage value (provide your answer in Comments) = 6 (50.0%)
Total votes = 12
________________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-3-EPOC list, click the following link:
https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-3-EPOC&A=1
"Full Name",Email,"Voting Member","Vote Date / Time",Answer,Comments
"Matthew Schmitt",m.schmitt@xxxxxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-28 15:15:27",single::::3:,None
"Marek Hajduczenia",marek.hajduczenia@xxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-28 15:16:07",single::::3:,"I do not understand why this needs to be limited by the standard in any way. This does not affect IOP between devices. "
"Hesham ElBakoury",hesham.elbakoury@xxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-28 15:18:30",single::1:::,
"Michel Allard",michel.allard@xxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-29 04:27:16",single::1:::,
"William Keasler",wkeasler@xxxxxxxxxx,N,"2013-05-29 07:55:26",single::::3:,"50%192 = 6 x 3250% allows up to 16 6MHz \"channels\" to be excluded(It would be useful to have input from \"global\" operators regarding their expectations/requirements for \"exclusion bands\")(specifically during early adopter phase and transition from analog or QAM distribution to IP based \"video\")"
"Mike Darling",mike.darling@xxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-29 08:36:25",single:::2::,
"Leo Montreuil",leo.montreuil@xxxxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-30 06:35:26",single:0::::,
"Avi Kliger",akliger@xxxxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-30 13:41:35",single::::3:,"This is a redundant specification as there is already a decision that minimal available bandwidth is 24 MHz "
"Duane Remein",duane.remein@xxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-31 06:59:08",single::::3:,"This is already covered by our rule of minimum 24 MHz contiguous spectrum."
"Bill Powell",bill.powell@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-31 10:29:29",single::1:::,
"tom staniec",tom.staniec@xxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-31 13:37:48",single:0::::,
"Saifur Rahman",saifur_rahman@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx,Y,"2013-05-31 14:31:39",single::::3:,25%
________________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-3-EPOC list, click the following link:
https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-3-EPOC&A=1