Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [802.19] TVWS Coexistence Plan - Deliverables



Steve,

I would suggest a fourth deliverable:

·         An IEEE 802.19 document on harmonized mechanisms to protect broadcast incumbents in TV white space:
        - common interface to the incumbent database with consistent query rate to free the TV channels within the timing specified by regulators,
        - harmonized sensing schemes requirements to meet the specified sensing threshold within adequate sensing time,
        - harmonized quiet period scheduling to sense incumbents while avoiding masking by other unlicensed devices,
        - etc.

Gerald


At 12:02 2009.04.03, Shellhammer, Steve wrote:

IEEE 802.19 TVWS Coexistence SG,

 

                I have been thinking about the best way to agree on a set of deliverables.  I recommend the following process.

 

1.       Select a set of possible deliverables This can be done on next week s conference call via email reflector

2.       Straw poll each of the possible deliverables to see if there is support for making it an actual deliverable This can be done via email.

 

I recommend on next week s conference call the SG develop the List of possible deliverables.   I will not be on the call so Ivan will run the call.

 

Here are my suggested deliverables,

 

·         An IEEE 802.19 document on coexistence scenarios of TV white space networks

·         An IEEE 802.19 document on coexistence metrics for measuring the level of coexistence between TV white space networks

·         An IEEE 802.19 document on coexistence mechanisms for enhancing coexistence between TV white space networks

 

On next week s call and via email please decide on any other potential deliverables.   I would expect all the deliverables to be documents of one form or another, but someone may have another idea of a good deliverable.  Ivan or Mark can then email me any other potential deliverables.

 

After we have such a list I will run an email straw poll to see how much support there is for each of these.  This is just a straw poll so we need to think about how much support is needed to decide that the SG wants to develop such a deliverable.  I will recommend that we only develop deliverables that receive 75% support.  If there is less support than that I would say that development of such a document would be optional.  I don t want to commit to developing something that has marginal support.

 

Regards,

Steve

 

 

From: whitespace@xxxxxxxx [mailto:whitespace@xxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Shellhammer, Steve
Sent: Tuesday, March 31, 2009 5:13 PM
To: 802. 19 TAG (stds-802-19@xxxxxxxx); 802TVWS (WHITESPACE@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx)
Subject: TVWS Coexistence Plan

 

All,

 

                On tonight s call we discussed the draft TVWS coexistence plan,

 

                https://mentor.ieee.org/802.19/dcn/09/19-09-0010-00-tvws-tv-white-space-coexistence-plan.ppt

 

                We will continue that discussion on next week s conference call.

 

                If you have comments on the plan you can also make those comments on the 802.19 email reflector.  If you are not already on the email reflector you can join here,

 

                http://ieee802.org/19/pub/subscribe.html

 

                If you have comments on the plan please be specific regarding what changes you would like to make to the document.  You can recommend adding text, changing text or removing text.  Please specify what changes you would recommend.   That would enable others to comment on your recommended changes.

 

Regards,

Steve