[STDS-802-16] P802.16-2004/Cor1/D4 Sponsor Ballot Recirc: Commentary Update posted

[Jonathan Labs <jlabs@WAVESAT.COM>]

Title: P802.16-2004/Cor1/D4 Sponsor Ballot Recirc: Commentary Update posted

All,

With Itzik's help I have reviewed the database of comments on P802.16-2004/Cor1/D4, and uploaded a revised version at:

        http://ieee802.org/16/docs/05/80216-05_065r1.zip.
 

Based on the reply comments and some offline correspondence, we have drafted proposed resolutions for all but 12 of the 56 comments in the database.  I will be entertaining a motion during the TG Maintenance session on Monday afternoon to accept the proposed resolutions of the following comments:

        002 (accepted)
        003 (accepted)
        004 (accepted)
        006 (accepted)
        007 (accepted)
        008 (accepted-modifed)
        009 (superceded by 010)
        010 (accepted-modifed)
        011 (accepted-modifed)
        014 (withdrawn)
        015 (accepted-modifed)
        017 (rejected)
        018 (accepted-modifed)
        019 (accepted)
        020 (accepted-modifed)
        021 (accepted-modifed)
        023 (accepted)
        024 (accepted)
        025 (accepted)
        026 (accepted)
        027 (accepted-modifed)
        028 (superceded by 030)
        029 (superceded by 008)
        030 (accepted-modifed)
        031 (accepted-modifed)
        032 (accepted-modifed)
        034 (accepted)
        035 (rejected)
        036 (accepted)
        037 (accepted-modifed)
        038 (accepted-modifed)
        041 (accepted-modifed)
        042 (accepted-modifed)
        043 (accepted-modifed)
        044 (withdrawn)
        045 (superceded by 008)
        047 (superceded by 008)
        046 (accepted-modifed)
        048 (accepted-modifed)
        049 (accepted)
        050 (accepted-modifed)
        051 (rejected)
      052 (accepted)  Note this one is a Coordination comment
        053L (accepted-modifed)

I ask everyone to review the proposed resolutions for this list closely, and if you have issues, to raise them by Sunday noon, Taipei time. Itzik will be starting the editorial work on these comments.

The proposed resolutions for the following comments were incomplete or unclear and need some additional work,  but the issues they address appear to have some level of consensus:

        012
        016
        040
        054L (looks like it can be harmonized with 055L)
        055L (looks like it can be harmonized with 054L)

I am working on the interested individuals to get these comments cleaned up, so they can be moved to the first list. 

The following comments I see as still having some controversy:

        001
        005
        013
        022
        033
        039
        056L

If these issues cannot be resolved offline before Monday afternoon, we will have to devote time then to resolve them.

Regards,
Jon