Re: [STDS-802-16] IEEE P802.16/Conformance04-1 Sponsor Ballot Recirc
The P802.16/Conformance04/D7 recirc is complete.
Only one comment (Comment #90) was received; it
was a coordination comment from IEEE editorial
staff noting that the draft "Has met all
editorial requirements."
Only two Disapprove votes remain, and only two
Disapprove comments (Comments #07 and #08) remain
unresolved. Both comments are from Rainer Ullman.
Mr. Ullman did not respond in the recirc. Comment
#8 was accepted verbatim, and Comment #7 was
accepted in principle.
The comment database has been updated:
http://ieee802.org/16/docs/06/80216-06_015r3.zip
The Conformance TG will meet at Session #43.
Gordon Antonello is unable to attend, so Herbert
Ruck will chair the meeting. The TG will have
little business. It will simply need to review
the status of the ballot and decide whether it is
complete.
Because the Conformance TG has so little business
to address, I have dropped its evening meeting,
which had been scheduled for Tuesday. Since this
left Tuesday open, I also moved the Maintenance
TG from Monday night to Tuesday night. We still
need to consider the possibility of adding a
fourth slot for the Maintenance TG.
Roger
>P802.16/Conformance04/D7 has been prepared by Editor Herbert Ruck:
> http://ieee802.org/16/pubs/P80216_Conf04.html
>
>from the Session #42 comment resolutions:
> http://ieee802.org/16/docs/06/80216-06_015r2.zip
>
>The draft is in Sponsor Ballot Recirc until 28
>April, per the announcement below from the
>IEEE-SA Balloting Center.
>
>Roger
>
>
>>Subject: Ballot Recirculation, P802.16-Conformance04
>>
>>Dear IEEE P802.16-Conformance04-1 Balloting Group Member:
>>
>>This e-mail is to advise you of the opening of
>>IEEE Standards Sponsor New Ballot Recirculation
>>- 1 for:
>>Title: Standard for Conformance to IEEE 802.16
>>- Part 4: Protocol Implementation Conformance
>>Statement (PICS) Proforma for Frequencies below
>>11 GHz.
>>Scope: This standard represents the Protocol
>>Implementation Conformance Statement (PICS)
>>Proforma, per ISO/IEC Standard 9646-7 (1995)
>>and ITU-T X.296, for conformance specification
>>of base stations and subscriber stations based
>>upon the air interface specified in IEEE
>>P802.16-REVd for frequencies below 11 GHz.
>>Purpose: This document describes the
>>capabilities and options within the air
>>interface specified for frequencies below 11
>>GHz in IEEE P802.16-REVd. It is to be completed
>>by the supplier of a product claiming to
>>implement the protocol. It indicates which
>>capabilities and options have been implemented.
>>It allows a user of the product to evaluate its
>>conformance and to determine whether the
>>product meets the user's requirements.
>>
>>***** IMPORTANT *****
>>If this is a recirculation of a Reaffirmation
>>Ballot, it may include amendments and/or
>>corrigenda to the base Standard.
>>
>>Since this is a recirculation ballot, you need
>>only respond if you wish to change your initial
>>vote. If you do not respond to this
>>recirculation ballot, your last vote will be
>>carried forward. Also, as this is a
>>recirculation ballot, a change to 'do not
>>approve' (i.e., a negative vote) which is
>>submitted with comments, shall be based only on
>>the changed portions of the balloted document,
>>clauses affected by the changes, or portions of
>>the balloted document that are the subject of
>>the unresolved negative votes." (IEEE Standards
>>Board Operations Manual, Part 5.4.3.2)
>>
>>BALLOT OPENS: 13-Apr-2006
>>BALLOT CLOSES: 28-Apr-2006.
>>No votes and/or comments will be accepted after
>>11:59 p.m. Eastern Time on the close date. Make
>>sure you review the document, cast your vote,
>>and submit your comments before the closing
>>date/time.
>>
>>***** TO ACCESS THE DOCUMENT, SUBMIT YOUR VOTE,
>>AND SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS *****
>>1. Log onto myBallot the IEEE Standards
>>Associationís (IEEE SA) Electronic Balloting
>>System, at
>>https://balloting.standards.ieee.org/my-site
>>2. Click on "Manage myBallot Activity." If your
>>logon provides Sponsor access, you must click
>>on myBallot Control Panel first.
>>3. Locate P802.16-Conformance04.
>>4. Click on the DRAFT# to open the
>>draft/standard; click on the drop-down box to
>>change your vote; click on the comments link to
>>submit your comments.
>>REMEMBER: This draft/standard is posted for
>>your review for balloting purposes only and
>>should not be copied or redistributed.
>>
>>NOTE: If you are fulfilling coordination duties
>>only, you will not be able to cast a vote.
>>Coordinators can only submit comments. Please
>>follow the instructions above to access the
>>document and submit your comments
>>
>>***** QUESTIONS *****
>>If you should have any questions about the document, please contact :
>>
>>or the Sponsor Chair:
>>ROGER B MARKS
>>r.b.marks@ieee.org
>>
>>***** myBallot QUESTIONS *****
>>If you should have questions about using
>>myBallot, please contact the IEEE-SA Balloting
>>Center at myBallot@ieee.org
>>
>>NOTE: To show our appreciation of your effort,
>>the names of all voters will be listed in the
>>front matter of the published standard. Your
>>vote and your contact information will *not* be
>>included.
>>
>>Thank you for your participation in this ballot.