Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [STDS-802-16] [MMR-AH-UM] Editorial comments on Usage Model Summary



Dear Ad hoc participants,

 

I’m forwarding Gamini’s email to the group. I’ve uploaded his proposed input to the following location: http://dot16.org/CSUpload//upload/temp_db/C80216j%2d06_UMAHtemp_Summary_section.doc.

 

I think that Gamini’s suggestions make sense and agree that we should use them in the document. I’ll add this to the agenda for the meeting.

 

Regards,

Jerry Sydir

 


From: Gamini Senarath [mailto:gamini@nortel.com]
Sent: Wednesday, June 21, 2006 11:42 AM
To: Sydir, Jerry
Subject: RE: [STDS-802-16] [MMR-AH-UM] Editorial comments on Usage Model Summary

 

Hi Jerry,

 

I have some suggestions for the Summary section. I have included the proposed changes to that table in the attached document. Please send it to the group. Thanks.. The changes are listed below:

 

(1) I think we should add a column called "Use Case Examples". This would include all the discussed use cases so that it would direct any reader to understand the specific modeling requirements such as different propagation and user distribution modeling, and understand most of the situations at once.

 

(2) I think the columns which contained the same for all the user cases can be taken out and mention as a note (see Notes (1) and (2). this would help clean up the table.

 

(3) I think the comments on Complexity should not be there. It gives the impression that only complex solutions are allowed for, for example, Mobile Vehicle usage scenario. ).

 

(4) We have not specifically address, "Coverage Inside Tunnels", in the document, other than covering the scenario when a train goes through a tunnel. (Fore example, when a vehicle without a relay undergo a tunnel).  I think we should include it. Due to its similarities with the in-building case, it may be included under "In-bulding" usage model (we can perhaps change the name to In-building/Tunnels?).

 

Regards,

 

Gamini