| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Avi,
Thanks for putting this list together! It has been very helpful in reviewing the contributions upload this past Monday. I
would like to point one correction regarding Motorola's contribution. Contribution IEEE C802.16m-007/123 should be
listed under both "pilot structure" and "physical
resource unit". Also, please update the first author. I believe
there was cut-and-paste error.
Thanks again!
Mark Cudak
Motorola Labs
From: stds-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG [mailto:stds-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG] On Behalf Of Avi Freedman Sent: Friday, March 14, 2008 5:09 AM To: STDS-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG Subject: RE: [STDS-802-16] [TGm] Contributions Hi
All, An updated TGm
contribution list for session 54 has been uploaded to the "Temp" directory.
It seems to me that
thanks to the upload server upgrade we have less documents out of sequence and
less confusion between "C" and "S" documents etc. There are still a few
documents with formatting problems, which will be handled at the chair's
discretion: 124r1 – Seems out of
scope of the designated topic 125r1: No need to
keep the instructions (in square brackets) within the cover page.
145, 146, 201, 217: See
below – no corrected version has been uploaded yet.
187r1, 188r2,
220r1: The new version was not updated in the document itself.
BR Avi From: Avi
Freedman [mailto:avif@HEXAGONLTD.COM] Dear
all I uploaded to the
"temp" directory an Excel file with all the contributions uploaded so far,
allocated according to their designated topic in the "Re" field or my wild
guess. Please have a look and see if I missed any document or wrongly assigned
them. Contributions with problems are marked in
red. A few more problems
with contributions: 121: No specific topic
allocation in the "Re" field 126r1: Wrong
document number in the header. The base document (126) does not exist, but
upload a corrected version as r2 174: No specific topic
allocation in the "Re" field. 181, 125: Wrong
document number (should be a C document, like the filename). Remove the editing
instructions from the cover page. 182: No "Re
field, wrong abstract, no "purpose". 191: It seems it
is just a commentary file. Any reason why was it uploaded as a contribution?
Please export it to a *.cmtb with the name
tgmsdd_YourName.cmtb 196: Wrong
document number in the header 201: Wrong
document number in the header 217: Wrong document
number in the header 227: No indication in
the "Re" field to which of the topics this contribution refers
to Avi From: Avi
Freedman [mailto:avif@hexagonltd.com] Dear
all, A new batch of
contributions has arrived in the TGm upload directory, ensuring us that we are
going to have, as usual, a wonderful busy time. Some of the contributions have
some problems. Please make an effort to fix them and upload a corrected version.
120: No specific
topic in the "Re" Field. The "Re" field should refer to a specific topic in the
Call for Contributions. Read the instructions in IEEE
802.16m-08/005 145, 146: No date,
no RE field 147: The "Re" field should refer to the
Call for Contributions. Read the instructions in IEEE
802.16m-08/005 C802.16m-08/159r1 is identical to
S802.16m-08/159. There is no need for the "S" document in this case. In the
document C802.16m-08/159r1 the slide show template was wrongly used. There is no
"Re" field. The "Venue" field in the "S" document is OK.
The same applies to the pair
S802.16m-08/137 and C802.16m-08/137r1. S802.16m-08/170,171: The "base
document" should be C802.16m-08/170,171 The following documents don't seem to
refer to the subject they were allocated to in the "Re" field, or to any of the
topics in the CfC: 124, 137, 159,
170 Avi |