[STDS-802-16] [16m][ARQ] Comment resolution on ARQ section
Dear All,
Please find the proposed resolutions to all the ARQ related comments
submitted to the Jeju session.
See table below for the proposed resolutions to these comments.
For some comments, as you can see in the table, the accepted text is
included in the document (C802.16m-09/2143r1) so that the chair/editor can
copy/paste the resolution from the document 2143r1 (during the comment
resolution in Tgm).
If your comments are included in the table below, please let me know if the
recommended comment resolution is not acceptable to you.
Regards,
Youngbin Chang
Samsung Electronics
1 List of comments on ARQ section in 80216-09_047r2
* Yellow comments: Commenter agreed with "Recommended Resolution"
Comment
Type
Commenter
Recommended Resolution
Remedy (Reject reason)
621
Technical
Anil
Agiwal
Accept
623
Technical
Joey
Chou
Reject
ARQ feedback IE is transported extended header or MAC control message.
624
Editorial
Jaesun
Cha
Accept
625
Technical
Ming-Hung
Tao
Reject
Overhead saving is not clear.
626
Editorial
Lei
Wang
Accept
627
Technical
Jaesun
Cha
Reject
Headers are merged into FPEH and MEH
628
Technical
Joey
Chou
Reject
Headers are merged into FPEH and MEH
629
Technical
Stavros
Tzavidas
Accepted-Modified
Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database
630
Editorial
Naftali
Chayat
Superceded
Superceded by 632
631
Technical
Vladimir
Yanover
Superceded
Superceded by 632
632
Technical
Jaesun
Cha
Accepted-Modified
C802.16m-09/1803r3
633
Editorial
Yih Guang
Jan
Superceded
Superceded by 632
634
Technical
Yang
Liu
Reject
There is not remedy. Problem description is not clear.
635
Technical
Lei
Wang
Accepted-Modified
Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database
636
Technical
Ronald
Murias
Superceded
Superceded by 635
637
Technical
Baowei
Ji
Accepted-Modified
Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database
638
Technical
Lei
Wang
R
MAC CRC does not necessary. ARQ can detect an error if ARQ block is missed,
which means that PHY CRC does not passed in HARQ layer.
639
Technical
Yang
Liu
Superceded
Superceded by 629
640
Technical
Lei
Wang
Accept
641
Technical
Yang
Liu
Superceded
Superceded by 642
642
Technical
Stavros
Tzavidas
Accepted-Modified
Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database
643
Technical
Ronald
Murias
Superceded
Superceded by 642
644
Technical
Yang
Liu
Accepted-Modified
Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database
645
Technical
Stavros
Tzavidas
Superceded
Superceded by 644
1655L
Technical
Youngbin
Chang
Accepted-Modified
C802.16m-09/2026r2
1656L
Editorial
Youngbin
Chang
Superceded
Superceded by 624
1657L
Editorial
Youngbin
Chang
Accept
1658L
Technical
Youngbin
Chang
Accept
1659L
Technical
Youngbin
Chang
Superceded
Superceded by #629
1660L
Technical
Youngbin
Chang
Accepted-Modified
C802.16m-09/2017r1
1661L
Technical
Youngbin
Chang
Accepted-Modified
Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database