Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

[STDS-802-16] [16m][ARQ] Comment resolution on ARQ section



Dear All, 

 

Please find the proposed resolutions to all the ARQ related comments
submitted to the Jeju session.

 

See table below for the proposed resolutions to these comments.

 

For some comments, as you can see in the table, the accepted text is
included in the document (C802.16m-09/2143r1) so that the chair/editor can
copy/paste the resolution from the document 2143r1 (during the comment
resolution in Tgm). 

 

If your comments are included in the table below, please let me know if the
recommended comment resolution is not acceptable to you.

 

Regards,

Youngbin Chang

Samsung Electronics

 


1         List of comments on ARQ section in 80216-09_047r2


 

* Yellow comments: Commenter agreed with "Recommended Resolution"

 


Comment

Type

Commenter

Recommended Resolution

Remedy (Reject reason)


621

Technical

Anil

Agiwal

Accept

 


623

Technical

Joey

Chou

Reject

ARQ feedback IE is transported extended header or MAC control message.


624

Editorial

Jaesun

Cha

Accept

 


625

Technical

Ming-Hung

Tao

Reject

Overhead saving is not clear.


626

Editorial

Lei

Wang

Accept

 


627

Technical

Jaesun

Cha

Reject

Headers are merged into FPEH and MEH


628

Technical

Joey

Chou

Reject

Headers are merged into FPEH and MEH


629

Technical

Stavros

Tzavidas

Accepted-Modified

Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database


630

Editorial

Naftali

Chayat

Superceded

Superceded by 632


631

Technical

Vladimir

Yanover

Superceded

Superceded by 632


632

Technical

Jaesun

Cha

Accepted-Modified

C802.16m-09/1803r3


633

Editorial

Yih Guang

Jan

Superceded

Superceded by 632


634

Technical

Yang

Liu

Reject

There is not remedy. Problem description is not clear.


635

Technical

Lei

Wang

Accepted-Modified

Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database


636

Technical

Ronald

Murias

Superceded

Superceded by 635


637

Technical

Baowei

Ji

Accepted-Modified

Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database


638

Technical

Lei

Wang

R

MAC CRC does not necessary. ARQ can detect an error if ARQ block is missed,
which means that PHY CRC does not passed in HARQ layer.


639

Technical

Yang

Liu

Superceded

Superceded by 629


640

Technical

Lei

Wang

Accept

 


641

Technical

Yang

Liu

Superceded

Superceded by 642


642

Technical

Stavros

Tzavidas

Accepted-Modified

Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database


643

Technical

Ronald

Murias

Superceded

Superceded by 642


644

Technical

Yang

Liu

Accepted-Modified

Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database


645

Technical

Stavros

Tzavidas

Superceded

Superceded by 644


1655L

Technical

Youngbin

Chang

Accepted-Modified

C802.16m-09/2026r2


1656L

Editorial

Youngbin

Chang

Superceded

Superceded by 624


1657L

Editorial

Youngbin

Chang

Accept

 


1658L

Technical

Youngbin

Chang

Accept

 


1659L

Technical

Youngbin

Chang

Superceded

Superceded by #629


1660L

Technical

Youngbin

Chang

Accepted-Modified

C802.16m-09/2017r1


1661L

Technical

Youngbin

Chang

Accepted-Modified

Copy the proposed text part regarding the comment in the C802.16m-09/2143r1
to the "Resolution" section in the commentary database