IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #11: Voting Report

"P802.16d: Draft Amendment to IEEE Standard for Local and Metropolitan Area Networks - Part 16:
Air Interface for Fixed Broadband Wireless Access Systems - Amendment 3: Detailed System Profiles for 2-11 GHz"

Status: This ballot is closed and complete as of 11 September 2003. The draft will not be submitted for Sponsor Ballot because the P802.16d amendment PAR was replaced by the P802.16-REVd revision PAR. The draft resulting from the ballot will be used as the basis of draft P802.16-REVd/D1, to be subject to Working Group Letter Ballot #13.

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #11b: Announcement {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18r12 (final, including comment resolutions and editor's notes)}

Question: To accept resolutions of comments from Working Group Recirculation Ballot #11a, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-03/18r8, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16d/D3-2003.
Closing date: 1 September 2003 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 10 August 2003
Ballot Submission Form

Recirc Ballot #1a Call for Reply Comments: 7-16 July 2003

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #11a: Announcement {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18r7}

Question: To accept resolutions of comments from Working Group Letter Ballot #11, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-03/18r3, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16d/D2-2003.
Closing date: 4 July 2003 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 4 June 2003
Ballot Submission Form
Letter Ballot #11 Call for Reply Comments: 5-9 May 2003 {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18r1}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #11: Announcement {CLOSED; see comment database 802.16-03/18}

Question: To forward IEEE P802.16d/D1-2003 for LMSC Sponsor Ballot.
Closing date: 1 May 2003 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 1 April 2003
Ballot Submission Form

Summary Results

Report Date Approve Dis Votes Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Approval
2003/09/01
(RB #11b:
Final
)
49
6
55
89.1%
Yes
3
58
70
82.9%
Yes
0
Yes*
2003/07/05
(RB #11a: Final)
44 11 55 80.0%
Yes 3 58 70 82.9% Yes 0 Yes*
2003/05/05
(LB #11: Final)
42 12 54 77.8% Yes 3 57 70 81.4% Yes 0 Yes*
*Pending resolution of comments, and then recirculation.

Ballot Details

[Note: "-" means "did not return a ballot".]

Name\Family Name\Given Vote: Letter Ballot #11 (Final) Vote: Recirc Ballot #11a
Vote: Recirc Ballot #11b
Agrawal Aditya Approve, No Comments

Antonello Gordon Approve, Comments Approve, Comments
Approve, Comments
Arefi Reza -

Arrakoski Jori Approve, Comments

Audeh Malik Approve, No Comments

Avivi Eli Approve, No Comments

Banister Brian -

Benyamin- Seeyar Anader - Approve, No Comments

Buskila Baruch -

Castelow
David


Comments only
Chang Dean Approve, No Comments Disapprove

Chayat Naftali Disapprove
Approve, No Comments
Chayer Rémi Approve, No Comments

Dick Stephen Approve, No Comments

Edmonston Brian Approve, No Comments

Eidson Brian Approve, Comments* Approve, Comments

Eilts Henry Approve, No Comments

Eklund Carl Approve, No Comments

Fan John -

Freedman Avraham Disapprove Approve, No Comments

Garrison G. Jack Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Goldhammer Marianna Approve, Comments

Hadad Zion Disapprove

Husson David Approve, No Comments

Joo Panyuh Approve, No Comments
Disapprove
Kaitz Tal Disapprove Disapprove
Approve, Comments
Kelly Phil Approve, No Comments

Kelman Ofer Approve, No Comments Approve, Comments

Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments

Kitroser Itzik Disapprove Disapprove
Disapprove
Klerer Mark -

Kolze Thomas Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Kuo Chun-Ming -

Labs Jonathan Disapprove
Approve, No Comments
Lee Seung-Hwan -

Leiba Yigal Disapprove Disapprove
Approve, Comments
Li Lingjie Approve, No Comments

Liebetreu John Approve, No Comments

Lindh Lars Approve, No Comments Approve, Comments
Lou Hui-Ling Approve, No Comments

Lycklama Heinz Approve, No Comments

Marks Roger Approve, Comments Approve, Comments

McKown Russell Approve, No Comments Approve, Comments
Approve, Comments
Middleton Andrew Approve, No Comments

Mody Apurva Approve, No Comments

Mollenauer James -

Murias Ronald Approve, No Comments

Nelson Robert Approve, Comments Approve, Comments
Approve, Comments
Reible Stanley Approve, No Comments

Robinson Gene Approve, No Comments

Roman Vincentzio -

Sarajedini Amir Approve, No Comments

Schwartz Randall -

Segal Yossi Disapprove Disapprove
Disapprove
Selea Radu Approve, No Comments

Simkins James -

Stanwood Kenneth Approve, Comments Approve, Comments

Struhsaker Paul Approve, No Comments

Taylor Shawn Approve, No Comments

Thomson William Approve, No Comments

Trinkwon David Approve, No Comments

Ullmann Rainer Disapprove
Approve, No Comments
van Waes Nico Disapprove Disapprove

Verbin Eyal Disapprove Approve, Comments
Approve, Comments
Wang Arthur Approve, No Comments

Wang Lei Approve, No Comments
Approve, Comments
Wang Stanley Approve, No Comments

Ward Robert -

Whitehead Philip Approve, No Comments

Wilson Joanne Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Yanover Vladimir Disapprove Disapprove
Approve, Comments
*Converted from Disapprove after ballot close.