Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [RPRWG] Propose the Amendment to Draft P802.17/D1.1 from Huawei

To:
Liu Enhui and
Li Jian
 
First I want to thank you and your team for continuing to look into ways to improve the 802.17 draft.  In addition, I want to address the procedural issues surrounding your request to have your proposal reviewed, and then to receive a response on that review.  I am addressing these issues for your benefit, and for the benefit of others that may have ideas on improving the 802.17 draft and are not certain on the best way to proceed to get their comments seriously considered.
 
All changes to the draft will be made as a result of resolving ballot comments.  Any balloters that support your proposal are free to point to sections of the draft they believe are currently deficient or wrong, and suggest your draft, or some modification of it as replacement text.  In addition, if any of the Ad Hoc groups embraces your proposal they may take it and possibly enhance it, and then present it as their collective proposal, in addition to referencing the proposal in their ballot comments on the draft. 
 
There is no individual or sub-group that has the right to express the views of the working group on a proposal that the working group has not reviewed and commented on by way of a formal motion.
 
Finally, one additional action that you can take to enhance the likelihood that your proposal will be carefully considered is to come to the January interim meeting and make a formal presentation on your proposal, explaining why it is necessary and what the resultant benefits are.  This final step should be in addition to having someone submit a ballot comment recommending the adoption of your proposal.
 
Note, details on registering for the January interim meeting, including making hotel reservations, are posted on
 
Best regards,
 
Robert D. Love
President, Resilient Packet Ring Alliance
President, LAN Connect Consultants
7105 Leveret Circle     Raleigh, NC 27615
Phone: 919 848-6773       Mobile: 919 810-7816
email: rdlove@xxxxxxxx          Fax: 208 978-1187
----- Original Message -----
From: Enhui Liu
Sent: Tuesday, December 10, 2002 9:24 PM
Subject: [RPRWG] Propose the Amendment to Draft P802.17/D1.1 from Huawei

Hi, all,
 
Our team have some comments on draft P802.17/D1.1.
Maybe Draft 2.0 will be released soon, but I think this still will be significant.
Please review and answer it. Thank you very much.
 
Introduction to the attached proposal£º
In the IEEE802.17 Draft D1.1, there are two kinds of wrap mode i.e. center wrap and edge wrap. Under the center wrap mode, the both sides of one station should make wrapping simultaneously, or there will be a wrong mode that will lead to packets lost. And normally for the two sides of one station, the state diagram are being executed independently and in parallel. So there should been a lot of communication between two sides. So we give a detail implement of state diagram based on  upon condition, including clear message sending and receiving between two sides of one station.
 
Regards,
Liu Enhui
Li Jian
Huawei technologies CO.,LTD.