Re: [802.21] Reminder - updated detailed proposals due Jan 9, 2005
Hi Ajay!
Merry X'mas!
As the holiday weekends draw closer, so does the submission deadline... :)
I have query regarding:
"
So an update from each proposer is mandatory, either in terms of
harmonization effort or an update in terms of more detail for the
January meeting.
"
If only a shared/harmonised presentation/document is submitted in Jan,
can individual presentations/documents be later submitted in Mar or May?
An example would be supposing there is harmonisation effort going on, I
doubt that it may be completed in time for the Jan meeting (and the 9th
Jan submission deadline!). Suppose that X and Y proposals are in the
process of being harmonised and the only 1 combined XY proposal is
submitted in Jan. Along the way there may be some disagreements in
certain parts of the proposal. In that case can X submit an additional
individual presentation in Mar or May even though X did not do so in Jan?
Regards,
Ben
Ajay Rajkumar wrote:
> Ben,
>
> The whole assumption going into the Phased Approach was that until these phases
> start there is active offline harmonization and "meeting of minds" taking place.
>
> So an update from each proposer is mandatory, either in terms of harmonization
> effort or an update in terms of more detail for the January meeting.
>
> For March meeting, there is an explicit requirement for more detail including
> explanatory text. One could not expect the group to vote on a proposal in phase
> II without details in advance.
>
> regards,
> -ajay
>
> On 12/13/2004 7:07 PM, Benjamin Koh Tien-Ming wrote:
>
>>Hi!
>>
>>"
>>3.1.10. Ajay: Encourage people to harmonize their proposals offline and
>>come back in Jan with more details. A
>>"
>>I somehow missed that...
>>
>>However, is it mandatory to have a presentation for Jan (if we do intend
>>to submit something for Phase I & II)? My feeling is that presentations
>>in Jan would be more voluntary in nature in order to garner feedback.
>>Correct me if the holiday mood is muddling my perceptions again! ;)
>>
>>Regards,
>>Ben
>>
>>
>>Ajay Rajkumar wrote:
>>
>>
>>>Ben,
>>>
>>>I agree what holidays, if you are still responding/reading this email!
>>>
>>>Refer to 3.1.10
>>>
>>>This was reiteration of what was stated during the meeting.
>>>
>>>-ajay
>>>
>>>On 12/12/2004 9:09 PM, Benjamin Koh Tien-Ming wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>>Hi!
>>>>
>>>>Is this update mandatory for all proposers that intend to submit a final
>>>>proposal in May?
>>>>As per the straw poll in the San Antonio meeting,
>>>>
>>>>"
>>>>3.1.6. How many participants are in favor of Option #3: Evaluation
>>>>guideline: Jan 2005; Phase I: Mar 2005; Phase II, May 2005. (For: 25;
>>>>Against: 0 Abstain: 3)
>>>>"
>>>>
>>>>So may I ask what is the purpose of the updated proposals in light of
>>>>the Phase I in March and Phase II in May?
>>>>
>>>>Thanks!
>>>>
>>>>Regards,
>>>>Ben
>>>>
>>>>Happy Holidays(?) to all reading this... :)
>>>>
>>>>Ajay Rajkumar wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>>Folks,
>>>>>
>>>>>As discussed and decided during the San Antonio meeting, this is just a reminder
>>>>>that the updated proposals from the proposers who had originally submitted
>>>>>proposals are due by January 9, 2005 (midnight EDT).
>>>>>
>>>>>These updated proposals are for further consideration and discussion by the group.
>>>>>
>>>>>Wishing you all Season's Greetings and Happy Holidays.
>>>>>
>>>>>Regards,
>>>>>-ajay
>>>>>Chair, IEEE 802.21 WG
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>--
>>>>/<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<++>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>\
>>>>| Benjamin Koh Tien-Ming |
>>>>| R & D Engineer |
>>>>| Panasonic Singapore Laboratories Pte Ltd |
>>>>| Tel: (65)6550 5481 Fax: (65)6550 5459 |
>>>>| E-mail: benjamin@psl.com.sg |
>>>>\>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>--<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<</
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>--
>>/<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<++>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>\
>>| Benjamin Koh Tien-Ming |
>>| R & D Engineer |
>>| Panasonic Singapore Laboratories Pte Ltd |
>>| Tel: (65)6550 5481 Fax: (65)6550 5459 |
>>| E-mail: benjamin@psl.com.sg |
>>\>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>--<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<</
>
>
>
--
/<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<++>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>\
| Benjamin Koh Tien-Ming |
| R & D Engineer |
| Panasonic Singapore Laboratories Pte Ltd |
| Tel: (65)6550 5481 Fax: (65)6550 5459 |
| E-mail: benjamin@psl.com.sg |
\>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>--<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<</